Welcome to Multi-Rotor UK. Please login or sign up.

Thursday,January 16, 2025, 19:53:42

Login with username, password and session length

Shoutbox

Bad Raven:
12 May 2024 08:13:51
 I have some F1 Abusemark boards going spare,,,,,,,,,,,,,    ;)    :azn
DarkButterfly:
11 May 2024 22:12:29
And with oldskool parts  :D
DarkButterfly:
11 May 2024 22:11:57
I must be the only one doing tricopters right now  :laugh:
DarkButterfly:
11 May 2024 22:09:30
 :D
Gaza07:
11 May 2024 21:15:16
Domain has been renewed closure has been cancelled  :D
Gaza07:
02 May 2024 08:07:52
Who are most people ??? I think the person you are referring to has put in a lot of effort to keep things moving  :rolleyes:
hoverfly:
01 May 2024 10:16:12
Most people I have spoken to are pizzed off with the yellow peril  flooding the forum,go figure. :whistling:
Gaza07:
23 Apr 2024 08:09:45
The Domain expires for the forum in 60 days, I'm not going to renew it this time unless I see any activity  :beer2:
Gaza07:
20 Apr 2024 18:02:50
Is there anyone who would like to see this forum stay open ? :shrug:
hoverfly:
17 Apr 2024 17:15:13
 :rolleyes:
Members
Stats
  • Total Posts: 201,503
  • Total Topics: 20,274
  • Online today: 53
  • Online ever: 530
  • (Tuesday,June 26, 2012, 08:34:46 )
Users Online
Users: 0
Guests: 25
Total: 25

Theme Changer





3d - Printworx

Comparison questions Mavic Pro vs Phantom 4 Pro

Started by Sharpe, Wednesday,June 21, 2017, 20:20:34

Previous topic - Next topic

Sharpe

Hi everyone,
New memeber abd total drone/RC noobie here (sorry!).

I want to get a camera drone and it';s down to either the Mavic, the Phantom 4 Pro, or waiting for Mavic 2/Phantom 5 (which may be a waste of time as they may still not be what I wsnt/need *if* they are even released in the next 6 months).

I have some questions I hope you guys can help me with. They are rather specific and more in the form of ';when comparing the two, is it a big/important difference or does it not really matter when it comes to either living with the drone, using it day to day or just in terms of the law of diminishing returns (ie yes it better but not *that much* better).

The questions:
Assuming I take the plunge rather than waiting for whatever DJI may release next and go for a Mavic Pro or a P4P, can anyone that has experience or good practical knowledge of both drones comment on how they compare on the following points?

1) Quality of still images - is the better camera on the P4P going to make a big difference vs the Mavic for stills, so much so that it';s worth loosing the portability of the Mavic? 

2) The quality of (still) image taken/lifted/cut from a 4k recording? (Noob here - I assume this is possible?)

3) Quality/stability of the FPV connection and overall connection/signal in terms of drop outs etc (I have heard Mavic is much better than P4P)?

4) Quality of the GPS signal and strength of antenna?

5) The importance of the 100Mbps bit rate on the P4P vs the Mavic';s 60Mbps (Noob here - if I am mostly in it for still image capture does it even really matter that much even if there is an important and noticeable difference)?

6) The ability to set the apature on the P4P vs inability on the Mavic?

7) Slow motion video. I know the P4P has the edge here but again - does it matter, do people feel like they are missing out when using their Mavic kind of thinking ';oh I wish I had the P4P for this?

Many thanks,

- Sharpe 



PS: In case it helps frame any answers, below is some context about my requirements and me to help frame any answers (if needed, if not just ignore ).

What I want to do with it:
Mostly: Take stills (panoramas).
Secondly: Just to fly around and explore. 

Where:
- Not abroad/on aircraft.
- Most of my flying will be done from a car/house with little or no walking requited.
- Some of my flying will be done from remote locations where I expect to take the drone in a backpack with me and walk for a few hours with it.
- I may occasionally want to just take the drone out and about with me on day to day trips out. 

About me:
- Not a pro photographer but understand the basics of shot composition & exposure etc (hoping to learn more with the drone). 
- I don';t (currently) own (or even know how to use) post processing software for my DSLR (although i would be looking to get into this for the drone footage/stills).
- I am very keen to get as much collision avoidance systems wherever possible. Although I will naturally be trying to fly above and/or away from collison risks to keep my drone safe and due to the types of photos I will want.
- Cost isnt a major factor to me, but I can';t afford (be allowed by wife) to, say, get a Mavic now and replace it in 2-3 years with the latest/better kit.

flycatchers

I like the comment I have read quite a few times that the best camera is the one you have with you.. I am going for a Mavic as I like the idea of being able to take it with me anywhere. Compact though the Phantom is- it still stays at home if I am going further than my local fields. The P4 Pro undoubtedly should give the best results of all the current consumer drones. But I have seen stunning photos and videos from the Phantom 2 with GoPro and Phantom 3 craft over the last few years. It is the skill of the operator that seems to make or break whether you get a good photo or interesting video. And eventually there will be a Mavic 2 and Phantom 5 which will be even better!! 
Phantom 1 with DYS smart 3 axis gimbal
Phantom 2 with Zenmuse H3 3D and FPV
GoPro Hero 3 Black